Lead generation agencies all promise more work. Some deliver. Some send thousands of careless emails in your name, burn your domain and leave you with nothing you own. These twelve questions sort them out in one call. Ask them of anyone, including us.
Ownership and control
1. Who owns the sending domain, the inboxes and the lead list?
Good answer: you do. They are bought in your name, on your accounts, and you keep them if you leave. Red flag: "We use our own infrastructure" with no way to take it with you. The reputation you pay to build should be yours.
2. Do I approve every prospect and every email before it sends?
Good answer: yes, in a shared sheet or dashboard, row by row. Red flag: "Trust us, we know what works." Your name is on every email.
3. Will you ever send from my main company domain?
Good answer: no, never: a separate lookalike domain only. Red flag: anything else. One bad campaign on your main domain can put your quotes and invoices in spam.
Results and reporting
4. What exactly counts as a result in your report?
Good answer: replies, quote requests and jobs you agree are a real fit. Red flag: opens, clicks, "impressions" or "meetings booked" that include no-shows, existing customers and people who were never going to buy.
5. Do you guarantee results?
Good answer: no, but here are the deadlines and process we do guarantee, and what you get if we miss them. Red flag: a guaranteed number of meetings. To hit it, agencies often lower the bar for what counts.
6. Can I see a sample before I pay?
Good answer: yes: real prospects in my trade and area, and the emails you would send them. Red flag: only case studies from other industries, or logos with no detail.
Money and terms
7. What is the full price, in writing, and what else will I pay?
Good answer: the fee, plus a clear list of your own costs (domains, inboxes, any data tools) and who you pay them to. Red flag: "It depends, let's get on a call" with no number, or set-up fees that only appear in the contract.
8. How long is the contract, and how do I cancel?
Good answer: a short pilot, then month to month; cancel by email. Red flag: a six- or twelve-month minimum before you have seen a single reply.
How the work is done
9. How many emails does each inbox send a day?
Good answer: under 30, spread over the working day, after a warm-up of two to three weeks. Red flag: hundreds per inbox, or "we start sending tomorrow" on a brand-new domain.
10. Where does the data come from, and is it verified?
Good answer: named decision-makers researched for your area, with every address verified before sending, and bounces kept under 2%. Red flag: "We have a database of millions" and no word on how it is checked.
11. Who will actually do the work?
Good answer: one named person or team, from the first list to the last report. Red flag: a sales rep now and an anonymous queue after you pay.
12. How do you handle opt-outs and CAN-SPAM?
Good answer: a postal address and a clear opt-out in every email, opt-outs suppressed at once across every inbox, and a list you can see. Red flag: a blank look. If they break the law, you can be held responsible too. See CAN-SPAM for trade owners.
Red flags at a glance
- Guaranteed meetings, or pay-per-appointment where no-shows count.
- Long minimum terms before you see results.
- They own the domains and the list.
- No price until a sales call.
- Emails sent without your approval.
- No word on volume, warm-up or verification.
A simple scorecard
| Question | Their answer | Good? |
|---|---|---|
| 1. I own domain, inboxes, list | ||
| 2. I approve every row | ||
| 3. Never my main domain | ||
| 4. Results = quote requests and real-fit jobs | ||
| 5. Process promises, not a meetings guarantee | ||
| 6. A sample before I pay | ||
| 7. Full price in writing | ||
| 8. Short pilot, cancel by email | ||
| 9. Under 30 per inbox a day, warmed up | ||
| 10. Verified data, bounces under 2% | ||
| 11. One named operator | ||
| 12. CAN-SPAM handled |
Ten or more good answers is a firm worth a pilot. Fewer than eight, keep looking.